Best Ricotta Cheese Brands: Bellwether Farms, Polly-O, Kite Hill & More

You’ll love how Bellwether Farms’ whole milk ricotta elevates sourdough pancakes and cheesecakes with its creamy, structured curds that hold up at 350°F without weeping, while Kite Hill’s almond-based ricotta delivers smooth, dairy-free richness in vegan cannoli. Polly-O’s part-skim version spreads easily in stuffed shells and resists graininess, and Lamagna’s clean-label ricotta performs flawlessly in no-drain lasagna. Each brand brings reliable texture, clean ingredients, and recipe-ready results straight from the spoon-discover which one fits your next bake perfectly.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more. Last update on 18th July 2026 / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API.

Notable Insights

• Kite Hill Ricotta offers a creamy, plant-based option ideal for vegan dishes, resisting curdling in baked and chilled recipes.
• Bellwether Farms Whole Milk Ricotta delivers luxurious texture and structural integrity, perfect for desserts and savory layered dishes.
• Polly-O Part Skim Ricotta provides consistent performance in cheesecakes and stuffed pasta, maintaining shape and smoothness.
• Lamagna Whole Milk Ricotta features a clean label and thick consistency, suitable for no-drain lasagna and versatile cooking.
• Calabro and Galbani ensure smooth, spreadable ricotta that enhances cannoli, baked ziti, and stuffed shells with reliable quality.

Kite Hill Ricotta, cheese, 8 Ounce

If you’re baking dairy-free cakes, folding ricotta into sourdough fillings, or topping pancakes with a creamy layer, Kite Hill Ricotta in the 8 ounce container is my go-to choice for a rich, plant-based swap that performs just like the real thing. Made from almond milk, it’s creamy, slightly sweet, with a buttery finish that blends smoothly into batters or spreads neatly on warm bread. I’ve tested it in lasagna, pancakes, even vegan cannoli-no curdling, no graininess. It’s dairy-free, soy-free, gluten-free, vegan, kosher, Whole30 approved, and Non-GMO Project verified, with zero artificial preservatives. Real testers note its rich texture stands up in baked goods, holds shape in fillings, and adds moisture without sogginess.

Best For: Those seeking a versatile, plant-based ricotta alternative that performs like traditional dairy ricotta in both sweet and savory recipes.

Pros:

• Creamy texture and rich flavor with a buttery finish, ideal for baking, spreading, or cooking
• Free from dairy, soy, gluten, and artificial preservatives; certified vegan, kosher, Whole30 approved, and Non-GMO Project verified
• Holds up well in baked goods, fillings, and sauces without curdling or becoming grainy

Cons:

• Made from almonds, so not suitable for those with nut allergies
• Higher price point compared to traditional ricotta or some other plant-based alternatives
• Limited availability in certain regions or smaller grocery stores

BELLWETHER FARMS Whole Milk Ricotta Basket, 12 OZ

I reach for BELLWETHER FARMS Whole Milk Ricotta Basket, 12 OZ when I want a ricotta that delivers clean, milky sweetness and a luxuriously smooth yet structured texture-ideal for filling citrus-kissed ricotta cakes, swirling into sourdough pancakes, or layering in no-bake desserts where mouthfeel matters. I love that it’s made by culturing whole milk for hours, developing natural acidity without vinegar. The careful, hands-on heating process preserves delicate curds, giving it a richer flavor and firmer body than most. At 12 ounces, it’s plenty for a 9-inch cake or a weekend’s worth of toast upgrades. It drains beautifully, never weeps, and holds its shape in baked applications-testers noticed fewer air pockets and more consistent spread.

Best For: Home bakers and gourmet cooks seeking a premium, naturally cultured ricotta with a rich, clean flavor and reliable texture for both sweet and savory applications.

Pros:

• Made with a slow-culturing process that develops natural acidity, resulting in a smooth, milky sweetness without vinegar
• Delicate curds are preserved through hands-on monitoring, delivering superior texture and consistency in baked and no-bake recipes
• Holds its shape well, drains cleanly, and resists weeping, making it ideal for layered desserts and spreads

Cons:

• Higher price point compared to mass-produced ricottas due to artisanal production methods
• 12-ounce size may be larger than needed for single-serving or small-batch uses
• Limited availability outside specialty grocery stores or online retailers

Polly-O Part Skim Ricotta Cheese (15 oz Tub)

Polly-O Part Skim Ricotta Cheese in the 15 oz tub stands out for home bakers and cooks who value consistency, clean handling, and a mild yet rich flavor profile that blends seamlessly into both sweet and savory dishes. I use it in cheesecakes, stuffed shells, and even swirled into sourdough dough for a softer crumb. Made with pasteurized milk and skim milk, it’s seasoned just right with salt, delivering a balanced taste without overpowering. The tub keeps it fresh, and the 15 oz size fits most recipes perfectly-no waste. It spreads smoothly, whips easily, and holds its structure in baked goods, giving them moisture and a subtle creaminess every time.

Best For: Home cooks and bakers seeking a reliable, versatile ricotta cheese with a smooth texture and balanced flavor for both sweet and savory recipes.

Pros:

• Made with pasteurized milk and skim milk for a lighter, part-skim option without sacrificing creaminess
• Convenient 15 oz tub packaging preserves freshness and reduces waste
• Delivers consistent performance in baking and cooking, from cheesecakes to stuffed pasta

Cons:

• Contains milk, making it unsuitable for those with dairy allergies or lactose intolerance
• Limited flavor variety due to standard seasoning with only salt
• Tub packaging, while convenient, may not be resealable after multiple uses

Generic Whole Milk Ricotta Cheese Lamagna 15 oz (Pack of 2)

When I need a ricotta that delivers clean flavor and consistent texture for both lasagna layers and lemon ricotta cakes, Generic Whole Milk Ricotta Cheese by Lamagna is my go-to-this 15 oz pack of two holds up in savory spreads and sweet fillings without overpowering other ingredients. Made with just milk, vinegar, and salt, it’s free from gums, starches, or whey by-products, giving it a naturally thick, creamy body I trust in no-drain recipes. Lamagna’s 90-year recipe shines: mild, slightly sweet, low-salt, ideal for layering in baked ziti or folding into sourdough cinnamon rolls. Shipped with gel packs, it arrives fresh, ready to elevate every dish.

Best For: Home cooks and bakers seeking a clean-label, versatile ricotta with a creamy texture and mild flavor for both savory and sweet recipes.

Pros:

• Made with simple ingredients: milk, vinegar, and salt, with no gums, starches, or whey by-products
• Thick, creamy consistency ideal for no-drain recipes and layered dishes like lasagna or baked ziti
• Mild, slightly sweet flavor with low salt content makes it adaptable for both savory and dessert applications

Cons:

• Requires refrigerated shipping with gel packs, which may increase delivery costs
• Generic branding may lack packaging appeal or detailed nutritional labeling
• Limited availability outside online channels due to perishable nature

Whole Milk Ricotta Cheese 15 oz

If you bake weekly or tackle homemade lasagna every other Sunday, a 15 oz container of whole milk ricotta cheese is your go-to for consistent texture and rich flavor without excess waste. I use mine in cheesecakes, stuffed shells, and even sourdough breakfast sandwiches, and it blends smoothly every time. The creamy, mild richness from whole milk holds up in bakes and folds into batters effortlessly. It’s soft, never grainy, and spreads evenly in dips or cannoli filling. Just keep it refrigerated-this perishable staple stays fresher longer when chilled. For real, reliable performance across both sweet and savory dishes, it’s a no-brainer.

Best For: Home cooks and bakers who regularly prepare both sweet and savory dishes and value a rich, creamy ricotta with minimal waste.

Pros:

• Rich, creamy texture from whole milk ensures smooth consistency in recipes
• Versatile use in a wide range of dishes, from lasagna to cheesecakes and dips
• Soft, uniform texture blends effortlessly into batters, fillings, and spreads

Cons:

• Perishable and requires constant refrigeration to maintain freshness
• 15 oz size may be too large for single servings or infrequent users
• Not suitable for those avoiding dairy or seeking low-fat cheese alternatives

Kite Hill Whipped Almond Ricotta (8 oz)

You’ll love Kite Hill Whipped Almond Ricotta if you’re vegan, dairy-sensitive, or simply exploring plant-based alternatives without sacrificing texture or flavor. I use it in both sweet and savory dishes, spreading it easily on warm sourdough or artisanal toast. Its 8 oz container holds enough for two generous servings, perfect for topping with roasted tomatoes, basil, or honey. The whipped, airy texture blends smoothly into stuffed shells or crostini, replacing traditional ricotta without heaviness. It’s dairy-free, soy-free, gluten-free, and Non-GMO Project verified, so I trust what I’m serving. I’ve even used it in cheesecake fillings-lighter but still creamy, with no artificial preservatives.

Best For: Vegans, dairy-sensitive individuals, or anyone seeking a creamy, clean-label plant-based ricotta alternative for both sweet and savory dishes.

Pros:

• Smooth, whipped texture that spreads easily and works well in recipes like stuffed shells or crostini
• Free from dairy, soy, gluten, and artificial preservatives, with Non-GMO Project verification
• Versatile for both sweet and savory applications, including toast toppings and cheesecake fillings

Cons:

• Smaller 8 oz container may not be cost-effective for frequent or bulk users
• Almond-based, so not suitable for those with nut allergies
• May have a milder flavor compared to traditional ricotta, requiring added seasoning in some dishes

Treeline Cheese – Vegan Non-Dairy Cashew Ricotta 7.5 oz, 6-Pack

This ricotta stands out for anyone following a vegan, gluten-free, or dairy-free diet without wanting to compromise on texture or taste-especially bakers and sourdough enthusiasts who need a reliable, creamy substitute in both sweet and savory applications. I use it in filled pastries, dolloped on sourdough toast, and folded into cake batters with great results. Made from cashews, filtered water, and live cultures, it’s naturally low in saturated fat, rich in protein, and free of coconut, palm, and soy oils. It’s creamy, slightly tangy, and holds up well when frozen or baked. At 7.5 oz per tub, the 6-pack lasts me weeks. Kosher Parve, Non-GMO, and responsibly sourced-it performs, nourishes, and aligns with my values.

Best For: Vegan, gluten-free, and dairy-free individuals seeking a creamy, versatile ricotta substitute that performs well in baking and savory dishes without compromising on taste or nutrition.

Pros:

• Creamy, slightly tangy texture ideal for both sweet and savory recipes, including pastries, toast, and baked goods
• Made from clean, plant-based ingredients with no coconut, palm, or soy oils, and naturally low in saturated fat
• Freezable, Non-GMO, Kosher Parve, and responsibly sourced, aligning with ethical and dietary values

Cons:

• Contains tree nuts, making it unsuitable for those with nut allergies
• Higher price point compared to some dairy or alternative ricottas
• Limited flavor variety within the product line for those seeking more diversity

Factors to Consider When Choosing Ricotta Cheese Brands

You’ll want to check if the ricotta is dairy-based or a non-dairy alternative like cashew or soy, especially if you’re baking vegan cheesecakes or stuffing shells for a dairy-sensitive crowd. Pay attention to texture and creaminess-some brands are grainy or watery, while others, like Calabro or Galbani, deliver a smooth, spreadable consistency perfect for filling cannoli or layering in lasagna. Look for clean ingredients, balanced saltiness, and a fat content around 10–15% to guarantee rich flavor and reliable performance whether you’re topping sourdough, baking cakes, or piping decorative rosettes.

Dairy Content And Alternatives

While traditional ricotta made from whole milk delivers a creamy, rich mouthfeel ideal for lasagna, stuffed shells, or ricotta toast on sourdough, it packs about 130 calories and 9 grams of fat per ¼ cup-something to weigh if you’re watching saturated fat intake. You can opt for part-skim ricotta, which cuts fat to 5–7 grams per ¼ cup using skim milk, keeping flavor mild and texture reliable for baking or spreading. If you’re dairy-free, try almond or cashew-based ricotta; these vegan versions have 50–80 calories per ¼ cup, zero lactose, and are made by culturing plant proteins to mimic dairy’s tang. They spread smoothly on sourdough, blend well into cheesecakes, and hold up in stuffed pastries without weeping. Look for fortified brands with added fiber and protein so you don’t sacrifice nutrition.

Texture And Creaminess Level

Creamy, smooth ricotta spreads effortlessly on sourdough and blends seamlessly into cheesecakes, thanks to its rich mouthfeel and fine texture, usually achieved with whole milk or premium plant-based bases like almond or cashew milk. You’ll want a soft, spreadable consistency-look for brands that finely process or whip their curds to avoid graininess, especially when layering in lasagna or dolloping on toast. High-quality ricotta holds together without watery separation, a sign of precise temperature control during production. Whole milk versions give you a fuller body, about 8–10% fat, ideal for lush fillings and tender cake batters. Part-skim types can feel lighter but sometimes lack depth. Plant-based options often use coconut oil or starches to mimic creaminess, staying stable when baked or chilled. Testers prefer those with a uniform, cloud-like texture-smooth through a pastry bag, rich without greasiness, and cohesive straight from the spoon.

Flavor Profile And Saltiness

Since flavor plays a crucial role in how ricotta performs in both sweet and savory applications, it’s worth paying close attention to the balance of richness, tang, and salt in your chosen brand. You’ll find whole milk ricotta delivers a creamier, more decadent taste, ideal for filling pastries or enriching sourdough-based dishes, while part-skim versions taste lighter, sometimes bordering on bland. Brands using cultured milk offer a pleasant tang that elevates cheesecakes and stuffed manicotti, whereas uncultured types can taste flatter. Watch sodium levels-some contain up to 150 mg per serving-excess salt can overpower delicate desserts or disrupt dough fermentation. Freshly made ricotta has a clean, slightly sweet profile testers love in cannoli fillings, while older batches develop sharpness. Plant-based options bring nutty or fermented notes and often rely on added salt to mimic cheese, so taste first before seasoning your dish.

Ingredient Simplicity And Purity

Look for ricotta with a short ingredient list: milk, vinegar, and salt are all you really need. You’ll get a cleaner product without gums, starches, or artificial preservatives muddying the flavor. Skip brands that add whey by-products or fillers-whole milk ricotta gives you a richer texture, pure taste, and better performance in delicate recipes. When you bake, especially in cheesecakes or stuffed pastries, simple ingredients mean predictable results and a creamy mouthfeel. Testers noticed less whey separation in ricotta without stabilizers, making it easier to measure-1 cup stays 1 cup. For sourdough fillings or light ricotta toast spreads, purity matters. You taste the milk, not chemicals. Brands relying on natural freshness instead of preservatives often use quicker turnover and better sourcing. If you’re decorating desserts or enriching cake batters, you want transparency. A short label means you’re adding quality, not hidden junk. Keep it real-your dishes deserve it.

Culinary Versatility And Use

When you’re layering lasagna, folding ricotta into cake batter, or spreading it over sourdough toast, the cheese’s texture and salt level make or break the dish. You want creamy, mild ricotta with a smooth consistency-it blends easily into fillings and batters without clumping. For toast or crostini, go for soft, spreadable types; they coat evenly and won’t tear bread. Thicker ricottas hold their shape in layered dishes, adding richness without seeping. Low-salt options give you full control over seasoning, whether you’re making savory ravioli or lemon ricotta cake. Look for brands that stay uniform when mixed-testers noted fewer lumps and better mouthfeel in cakes and stuffed shells. Dairy-free versions should resist separation when baked; top performers stayed cohesive at 350°F for 30 minutes. Choose wisely, and your ricotta will shine across sweet and savory recipes.

Certifications And Dietary Needs

You’ve got the texture and flavor down pat, but your ricotta choice doesn’t end at creaminess or salt level-certifications play a key role, especially when baking for specific diets or serving guests with dietary restrictions. Look for labels like Non-GMO Project verified, gluten-free, or Kosher Parve, which confirms no milk or meat derivatives-ideal for kosher kitchens. If you’re making lasagna for a lactose-sensitive guest, grab a dairy-free or lactose-free ricotta alternative; many coconut or almond-based versions whip up smooth, holding 1:1 swap ratios in recipes. For Whole30, choose brands approved, skipping dairy, added sugars, and fillers. Soy-free and sesame-free options prevent allergen exposure, a must when serving diverse crowds. Testers found certified ricottas performed evenly in cheesecakes, with no curdling, and held structure in stuffed shells. Always scan for allergen statements-certifications aren’t just labels, they’re peace of mind baked right in.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Ricotta Cheese Safe for Lactose-Intolerant Individuals?

You can eat ricotta if you’re lactose intolerant, but proceed carefully. Ricotta’s made from whey and has less lactose than milk, yet it still contains some. Small portions, like 1/4 cup in cheesecake or stuffed shells, often cause no issues. Opt for brands labeled “low-lactose” or pair with lactase enzyme pills. Test with a tablespoon first to gauge tolerance, and always check labels for milk solids.

Can I Freeze Ricotta Cheese for Later Use?

You can freeze ricotta, but you’ll notice texture changes once thawed-it’ll be grainier and release more water. For best results, drain excess liquid first, then freeze in an airtight container for up to two months. Thaw overnight in the fridge and stir well before using. Testers found it still works great in baked dishes like lasagna or ricotta toast, where texture matters less. Avoid using thawed ricotta for delicate frosting or filling applications.

How Long Does Opened Ricotta Last in the Fridge?

You can keep opened ricotta in the fridge for about 5 to 7 days, max. Store it in an airtight container, submerged in a bit of whey or cold water to prevent drying. Change the liquid daily to maintain freshness. Testers noticed texture degrades faster if left uncovered or in the original packaging. For best results in fillings or frosting, use it within 3 days-it’s creamier and holds structure better, especially in cheesecakes or layered desserts.

What Dishes Work Best With Vegan Ricotta Alternatives?

You’ll love using vegan ricotta in lasagna, stuffed shells, and manicotti-it holds shape and moisture well, just like dairy ricotta. Try it in cheesecakes or dolloped on sourdough toast with olive oil and red pepper flakes. It works great in filled pastries like ravioli or cannoli, and spreads smoothly on bagels. Testers report creamy texture and mild flavor, especially in baked applications where it doesn’t separate. Use 15-ounce containers just like traditional ricotta in 1:1 swaps.

Does Ricotta Cheese Contain Gluten?

You’re safe to use ricotta cheese in your gluten-free baking-it doesn’t contain gluten unless additives or flavorings sneak in. Always check labels, especially with flavored or shelf-stable versions. In sourdough, ricotta adds moisture and tenderness; in cakes, it boosts richness without weighing them down. Testers love its smooth lift in cheesecakes and filled pastries. Stick to fresh, whole-milk ricotta at 16% fat or higher for best results, every time.